Older drivers, what is your point?

Two surveys reported in the press recently caught my attention.  One was taken by Saga, surveying 10,000 people, and the other by a well-known insurance company involving 1,500 drivers.

The Saga survey concluded that half of those over 50 say they would be happy to take a test at the age of 70 to prove they were still competent.  Seventy percent of those surveyed said that anyone involved in a serious accident, or who had accumulated a lot of penalty points, should be made to take a test.  I guess the implication here was for older drivers, but it does say anyone!  Especially in these days where any hint of discrimination gives everyone the vapours.

What does “a lot of penalty points” mean anyway?  Surely you lose your licence when you get more than 12.  Isn’t that the whole point?  Well, it seems not.  Looking up some published figures on this, I found the top 20 expert points collectors.  Number 20 is a woman in Huddersfield who has 28 points.  The numbers climb steadily to number 1, a man in London, who has 45 points.  Apparently a court can decide not to impose a driving ban over 12 points where undue hardship will result.  All very well, but 45 is just taking the mickey!

Going on age alone is hardly an effective approach.  There are currently 4.6 million licence holders aged 70 and over.  In ten years’ time that is likely to rise to 6.5 million.  The report included a comment from a Saga director; “Drivers in their 70s tend to have fewer accidents per miles driven than drivers in their 20s.  Older drivers tend to have low-speed accidents.  They tend to hit stationary objects where younger drivers have accidents at higher speeds”.

So, if we are talking about making people take the test again, and we are not happy with age alone as a criterion, how about penalty points.  If you draw a graph (don’t worry I haven’t included the graphs) of the number of licence holders with points in age groups from 17 to 100, it climbs to a peak at 43 and reduces to age 70 where it drops right away.  If you then adjust that graph to take account of the number of licence holders in each age group it moves to the left.  There is now a broad plateau from 20 to 40 and then a straight drop off with increasing age.

If we do a similar exercise with driver death rates, the graph is high from 17 to 20, it then declines to a minimum at age 60-69 and then rises slightly for 80 plus.  If that graph is adjusted to account for average miles driven in each age group it is even higher on the left (17 to 20) dropping to a broad minimum between 30 and 69 with a slightly sharper rise for 80 plus than before.  People calling for further testing of older drivers need to point to the statistics that suggest it is necessary rather that the “common sense” often quoted or the rare case of an elderly driver going the wrong way down the motorway which catches press attention.

The second survey I mentioned tested people on their knowledge of road signs.  One in three couldn’t identify the national speed limit for cars or the sign for one-way traffic.  Ninety percent had no idea of the meaning of double yellow lines!  Of the 1,500 drivers interviewed, only 2 answered all 15 questions correctly.  The average score was eight.  Despite this, 80% claimed to be a safe driver.  Department of transport figures show that road deaths numbered 1780 in the 12 months to September last year.  An increase of 49 on the previous year.  A spokesman for the insurance company concerned said “Most of us think of ourselves as safe drivers and we try to follow the rules of the road but as our study shows we might not always know what those rules are.”  Let’s keep up the good work folks.

John Norrie

Group Chairman



4 thoughts on “Older drivers, what is your point?

  1. As a recently enrolled associate, one of the phrases I have heard stated most often is the high numbers of drivers who regard themselves as “a safe driver” &/or an “above average driver”
    This article alone states a figure of 80%.
    I enrolled as an associate because, as someone approaching my 70th birthday in May, and believing myself the be, in my opinion, “a fairly good driver” I wanted to find out whether my opinion was based on groundless supposition, a generous application of ego, or just sheer age induced fantasy.

    DVSA steered me toward (NAM) IAM RoadCraft.

    Having now been out on a number of observed drives, I can honestly say that I have had to face up to the grim realisation that my claim to proficiency was based upon nothing more than that which I chose to believe, without any real evidence to justify the supposition. There was no factual evidence to support my assertion, except by comparison with other drivers. And of course, the failing of that premise was that it centred around my opinion of other drivers, and my opinion of my own ability
    (not a recommended or universally approved research model)

    Whether I am any good or not is overwhelmed by the realisation of how much I have had to learn, simply to begin to comply with the IPSGA system.
    I have been challenged in a manner which I did not expect.
    And I have been humbled into ackowledging that I am nothing like as good as I thought I was.
    I would suggest that any motorist who has little or no understanding of the IPSGA system, cannot possibly be as good as they imagine themself to be.
    It really is a testing system, with its practicality being so definitive.
    You either are an IPSGA driver, or you’re not; and if you’re not, it’s possible that you really are not quite as good as you think you are. 😃

    Perhaps IAM RoadCraft should introduce a formet entitled IAM Mature Motorists, which anyone attaining the age of 70 has to participate in, so that reality can graciously and eloquently address the possible areas of fantasy.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s